Sunday, April 14, 2002
7:16 pm
Off her trolley
The gossip of the past few days about Guardian columnist Julie Burchill's tryst with right wing comic Jim Davidson sounded ridiculous.
Then I read this column:
The fact is that believing we have the right to "give away" people who want to stay British is as reactionary, rightwing and imperialist as forcing people to be British when they don't want to be.
She's saying that the British governing classes have no right to give away the left over colonies because these people "want to be British".
Now I'm not imperialist but I'll yield to no man (or Julie) in my reactionary and right wing credentials. And giving away colonies is perfectly reactionary and right wing.
If 2000 transplanted Welsh sheep farmers in the South Atlantic or 20 000 Andalucian dock workers on the Spanish coast want to be British, why should the home population, all 60 million of us, have to suffer lower security because of it?
The continued Britishness of these colonies should be dependent on their utility to the mother country and nothing else. While I accept that Gibraltar may still provide some rationale by helping to protect the sea lanes leading to us, the Falklands stopped being useful in that respect when the Panama canal was opened in 1914. Do we really need wool and squid enough to keep a long distance task force in battle condition?
We were right to fight for the Islands in 1982, because to do otherwise would have shown a weakness that would have invited yet more problems. It was not a matter of honour, but of practicality.
Thatcher was right to fight in 1982, yet she was also right to try and give the islands away a year earlier.
So, yes, Julie, it may be right wing to put the interests of the metropolitan power ahead of outlying islands half way round the world. It is also right.
That stuff about Jim Davidson and Julie Burchill was not actually true, I just put it in to baffle the American readers and to confuse those of you who don't bother to read to the end.
Links
- Ishtar Talking
- Korea Life Blog
- Toothing
- Academic Secret
- Genius Duck
- Hairstyles and Nails
- Home Tips
- Health Talk and You
- Beadle Beads
- Glass Beads Supplies
- Paquet Full of Glass
- Native American Jewelry
- Blogopoly
- Second String Swap
- Work at Home News
- Bashhh
- Click Here
- Click Here
- Just Another Opinion Blog
- Dip Dot
- Awryt
- Zacquisha
Blog Archive
-
▼
2002
(915)
-
▼
April
(80)
- Where's Osama? Just asking.
- Chasing Turkey From Auntie: The Turkish Governme...
- Interviewing Le Stylo John Laughland interviews L...
- Bear with me I lost my template, so the comments ...
- Konspiracy Korner Never ever claim that I'm not g...
- Mark Steyn jumps the Shark That patron saint of t...
- Is Le Pen a man of the Left? Mark Steyn states: ...
- What was he doing here, anyway? One of the good t...
- Jim Henley points out what I've got to say on Le P...
- Our Partners in Europe Five British plane-spotter...
- You're either with us... On the Irish theme, here...
- No, Le Pen's not one of the nice guys What is The...
- So the Peace Process is a success? This is from a...
- Bud nipping For all our sneers and jeers at Franc...
- There will always be an England A little over a y...
- Collective Guilt - a dodgy concept Why do all Lib...
- Narrower still and narrower Christopher Montgomer...
- Some comment on the Andrew Alexander piece from ...
- In case you weren't told... British troops in sec...
- At Last, a reason to vote for Le Pen Le Pen pledg...
- Regional Base An interesting map shows who won wh...
- Who's the Daddy? My biggest ever daily hit rate (...
- Welcome Strangers For all the Raimondo readers yo...
- Questions on Le Pen Put your questions to the BBC...
- Good point Peter Briffa points out that: Le Pen ...
- Over at antiwar.com At my old scratching ground t...
- Apres le deluge An embittered old man with extens...
- And it hits the fan If the early results are to b...
- No title
- Why independence matters Bruce Anderson writes an...
- Better late than never It's the debate on the Mid...
- Iain Dale points to an interesting phenomenen, Bri...
- Web Log Ping Pong Natalie Solent asks, "can herea...
- The Eurosceptic case for Brown What is the bigges...
- Was the Soviet threat bogus? Andrew Alexander arg...
- Apart from killing millions of innocent people... ...
- It should at least be funny Is calling for the in...
- The material importance of Geography I have been ...
- All for One & One for All. I hope this will not b...
- Genocidal, moi? Natalie Solent takes me to task o...
- Something odd about Ariel So all us peaceniks che...
- Reader Feedback Why not actually write to her, I ...
- Other Stuff So Tony Blair says to his press secre...
- Off her trolley The gossip of the past few days a...
- Matthew Parris has words of warning for the peacen...
- How'd that happen? Chavez returns to power Vene...
- Amateur Hour Why those wacky Lib Dems, always the...
- Who said that? Obviously we are at the limits of ...
- Ode to Chavez So farewell then Hugo Chavez of Ven...
- Here's a link to yesterday's Prime Minister's Ques...
- Thanks for asking, but... No, I'm not Eric Blair ...
- Parliament to discuss foreign policy - shock Nick...
- Why Blair won't be the next Ramsay MacDonald Blai...
- Israel, Palestine and the Blogosphere Israel is a...
- The Continuing Success of Intervention. Item 236 ...
- The Continuing Success of Intervention. Item 235 ...
- Mark Steyn is straight... ... and so is Conrad Bla...
- The Continuing Success of Intervention. Item 234 ...
- The Continuing Success of Intervention. Item 233 ...
- Monty's Back My improvement at antiwar.com has su...
- I've found this old article by my hero Correlli Ba...
- My piece on Israel has been linked by Metafilter a...
- A right wing case against the invasion of Iraq, la...
- Are we expecting too much of Israel I don't know ...
- This coup in Afghanistan, maybe its not really a c...
- These are our allies Julian Manyon pours scorn on...
- Hubris According to Nick Robinson: Powerful peop...
- No, it's not idealistic I really admire Fred Prui...
- Outraged HOW DOES TONY BLAIR GET AWAY WITH IT? as...
- Non Sequitor of the day African nations still was...
- Here's an old article by Dan Plesch of the Royal U...
- Blair sorts out the Middle East It must be true, ...
- Peace in Afghanistan An "attempted coup" has been...
- Labour rebels are rallying round opposition to an ...
- Are they stupid, or just dishonest? Christopher M...
- It's not about hurt feelings, Tam What is it abou...
- Stirrings on the Right This could be promising, M...
- Could Spell Trouble Labour's euro dissidents to b...
- New Link Gary Farber has a reciprocal link. I've...
- Given the nod I've been mentioned by Glenn Reynol...
-
▼
April
(80)
0 comments:
Post a Comment