Saturday, November 16, 2002
1:45 pm
Oxymoron: Libertarian Realpolitik - 16th November 2002, 13.45.
Seth Fehrs of libertyforall puts forward a libertarian solution to the problems of the Middle East: a peace treaty between Israel and the Arab states with the United States as guarantor and Turkey providing peacekeeping troops. The US would remove all troops from the Middle East.
Removal of all US forces from the region and a pledge to end US meddling in the internal affairs of all treaty nations.
Turkey would be included in the treaty, along with as many nations as possible from approximately Egypt to Afghanistan.
Pledges that an attack on any treaty nation would be viewed as an attack on them all. This is includes recognizing Israel as a nation and member of the treaty, and sincere efforts to eliminate terrorist organizations.
Israel cedes Palestine as a fully independent country and allows limited Arab pilgrimages to Jerusalem. Roughly speaking, Palestine would consist of territories seized in the 1967 war.
The United States agrees to come to the protection of Israel, and other member states who ask, in the event of a total breakdown of the treaty that results in war. [This part of the treaty might be optional, seeing as Israel has survived so far.]
The only problem is that the article presumes all parties would respect international law and underestimates the religious hatred that motivates many Arab states. I cannot see Arab states ganging up on one of their own if it attacks Israel.
Seth Fehrs of libertyforall puts forward a libertarian solution to the problems of the Middle East: a peace treaty between Israel and the Arab states with the United States as guarantor and Turkey providing peacekeeping troops. The US would remove all troops from the Middle East.
Removal of all US forces from the region and a pledge to end US meddling in the internal affairs of all treaty nations.
Turkey would be included in the treaty, along with as many nations as possible from approximately Egypt to Afghanistan.
Pledges that an attack on any treaty nation would be viewed as an attack on them all. This is includes recognizing Israel as a nation and member of the treaty, and sincere efforts to eliminate terrorist organizations.
Israel cedes Palestine as a fully independent country and allows limited Arab pilgrimages to Jerusalem. Roughly speaking, Palestine would consist of territories seized in the 1967 war.
The United States agrees to come to the protection of Israel, and other member states who ask, in the event of a total breakdown of the treaty that results in war. [This part of the treaty might be optional, seeing as Israel has survived so far.]
The only problem is that the article presumes all parties would respect international law and underestimates the religious hatred that motivates many Arab states. I cannot see Arab states ganging up on one of their own if it attacks Israel.
Links
- Ishtar Talking
- Korea Life Blog
- Toothing
- Academic Secret
- Genius Duck
- Hairstyles and Nails
- Home Tips
- Health Talk and You
- Beadle Beads
- Glass Beads Supplies
- Paquet Full of Glass
- Native American Jewelry
- Blogopoly
- Second String Swap
- Work at Home News
- Bashhh
- Click Here
- Click Here
- Just Another Opinion Blog
- Dip Dot
- Awryt
- Zacquisha
Blog Archive
-
▼
2002
(915)
-
▼
November
(54)
- Blair's view - 30th November 2002, 21.37 Tony Bla...
- No less determined to integrate - 30th November 20...
- Where do the smaller states stand? - 30th November...
- Euronitis - 30th November 2002, 20.25 Last week, ...
- Not good - 28th November 2002, 22.41 Current deve...
- Do I look big in this? - 28th November 2002, 22.14...
- Will London be a target? - 28th November 2002, 22....
- And what will we do when we get there? Once again...
- Err, Turkey's not in Europe Srdja Trifkovic pours...
- Should Parliament vote to deploy troops? - 25th No...
- Falling between two stools - 25th November 2002, 2...
- Giscard D'Estaing, Defender of Christendom - 26th ...
- Wooing the West - 25th November 2002, 22.38 Over ...
- Leave Us Alone - 24th November 2002, 20.37 At fir...
- The Axis Powers strengthened - 24th November 2002,...
- The Role of Religion in the European Constitution ...
- Lost an enemy, yet to find a role - 23rd November ...
- Senescence - 21st November 2002, 22.36 When an in...
- What is Netanyahu playing at? - 21st November 2002...
- Is it beginning to strike a nerve? - 21st November...
- From Vancouver to Vladivostok - 19th November 2002...
- An Overview - 19th November 2002, 21.28 Here's a ...
- Rapid Reaction NATO - 18th November 2002, 22.02 U...
- Hear, Hear - 18th November 2002, 21.56 Tony Benn ...
- Worth the Risk? Terrorism is something that intru...
- North Americans Turfed Out (NATO) - 17th November ...
- United States refuses to support hate speech resol...
- Second Most Powerful Nation - 17th November 2002, ...
- Cyanide Plot - 16th November 2002, 23.10 Terroris...
- Libertarian Defence - 16th November 2002, 13.58 F...
- German Libertarianism - 16th November 2002, 13.52 ...
- Oxymoron: Libertarian Realpolitik - 16th November ...
- The Tories have signed up to this - 15th November ...
- Romano Prodi Muses - 15th November 2002, 21.36 An...
- The only realist stance In the National Interest,...
- Empty Cooing Mick Hume takes apart the convention...
- A "Ring of Friends" - 13th November 2002, 22.06 I...
- Skating away on the Thin Ice of the New Day 12th N...
- Still Legal This should worry all web loggers. T...
- More Demands 12/11/02 23rd July 1914: The Austro...
- Anti-Americanism: How powerful is it? 11th Novembe...
- The Russia-EU Summit 11th November 2002, 23.18 An...
- Libertarian and National Defence 11th November 200...
- Royal Intrusion So who was Charles's man accused ...
- Wrong, wrong, wrong Seems like a few helpings of ...
- UNanimity 10th November 2002, 22.55 It is now cle...
- Domestic Politics Intrusion Is IDS finished? Pro...
- Referendum on an E.U. Constitution? No Chance. 7...
- Levelling the Playing Field - 4th November 2002, 2...
- Are we living in Cloud Cuckoo Land? 3rd November 2...
- Zimwatch: Government capabilities are failing 2nd ...
- The Whig View of the EU - 2nd November 2002, 19.20...
- Plagiarism 1st November 2002, 23.36 GMT No excuse...
- PFI Friday - 1st November 2002, 19.47 GMT With th...
-
▼
November
(54)
0 comments:
Post a Comment