Friday, September 06, 2002
4:19 pm
Devil or deep blue sea?
David Carr over at Samizdata has tried to make a case for invading Iraq from the national interest. Unlike the leadership of the Conservative Party, or the editorial boards of the Black and Murdoch papers he doesn't come up with some laughable idea like "Saddam's got missiles aimed for London" or "he's another Hitler".
The idea is this. European integration is a more imminent threat to British than American power. Supporting America is going to harm the cause of European integration in Britain.
First let it be said that this is a far better argument than other attempted right wing justifications I have seen (including the other ones in Samizdata). And it rests on a truth. At this point in time European integration is more of a threat to British independence than American power.
Where I disagree is on the effect that an invasion will have on the Euro debate and the absence of alternatives.
Firstly to the absence of alternatives. Mr Carr's thesis rests crucially on the idea that the only alternative to European union is being a junior partner in the American Empire. As a site devoted to maintaining just such an alternative you can expect us to disagree with this idea. But this at least deserves an explanation as to why our national survival is not a lost cause.
Britain is still large, prosperous and powerful enough to maintain itself as an independent state. There is plenty of disagrement as to how powerful the British armed forces are. What cannot be doubted is that they would be powerful enough to protect the rather defendable British Isles from invasion. As the world's fourth largest economy she is also capable of paying her way in the world. All that would be needed in normal times is to avoid unnecesary foreign entanglements and Britain, or for that matter England, could maintain an independent existence into the foreseeable future.
I'm not sure whether Mr Carr disagrees with this, although many of his Anglospherist colleagues need a reminder of this reality. However, where Mr Carr does disagree is on the political reality.
However the question is not whether Britain can survive outside both the American and Belgian Empires, it is about the political day to day reality. So my second disagreement with Mr Carr's political thesis comes out.
What would the effect of the war be on the European question?
The idea is that Tony Blair will not be President of Europe while he is so keen on kow towing to the President of America.
It is certainly true that the war is unpopular in Europe, as can be seen from Chancellor Schroeder's return from the political grave. This is a German chancellor who has presided over a perceived increase in prices, and a left wing leader who's presided over a very real increase in unnemployment. By all political laws the man should be politically brown bread. He is however still in with a shout very largely down to his opposition to the war. (Of course you can't expect the denizens of Conservative Central Office to notice something so vulgar as representing the popular will. This however is a private gripe.)
However what was the issue with which Herr Schroeder barn stormed the country last time? Why a scepticism towards the Euro. And M Jospin in France before him. The lesson here is that the European leaders will not do what they are told by the electorate, but what they are told to do by their peers. When it comes to the war the Europeans will do nothing but sulk on the sidelines. There'll be no UN vetoes from France and no blocking of our Tone to be President of Europe. My initial reaction was admittedly that Tony's Presidential chances were gone, but this was over-estimating the attachment to the popular will in Europe, or the guts to carry out a meaningfully independent foreign policy.
So where will this leave us with the Euro debate. Well, if there is popular enthusiasm for the war then it may not make the government more popular, or even Tony Blair, but people will start to respect him once again. As it is Tony Blair's power of persuasion that is the only thing that could lead us into the Euro, is our entry into the Euro more or less likely?
And if the British public dislike the war or its aftermath, what then? Will the British feel repulsed from their European neighbours? There is a danger of creating a genuine popular desire for Europe.
So British entry into the war is a lose-lose proposition for those who wish to maintain Britain's financial independence.
Of course, there may be a bright spot here. If the Labour revolt grows then Mr Blair's position as Labour leader may be under threat. The biggest threat to British independence is adoption of the Euro, and it's biggest proponent is Mr Blair. So the war could help us with the Euro.
One would say that the downside, overstretch of British forces and involvement in a Middle Eastern argument that is none of our business, is far more likely than any upside envisaged by myself or Mr Carr.
Links
- Ishtar Talking
- Korea Life Blog
- Toothing
- Academic Secret
- Genius Duck
- Hairstyles and Nails
- Home Tips
- Health Talk and You
- Beadle Beads
- Glass Beads Supplies
- Paquet Full of Glass
- Native American Jewelry
- Blogopoly
- Second String Swap
- Work at Home News
- Bashhh
- Click Here
- Click Here
- Just Another Opinion Blog
- Dip Dot
- Awryt
- Zacquisha
Blog Archive
-
▼
2002
(915)
-
▼
September
(69)
- Marching Season 150 000 may be less than half th...
- A little article in the Economist about how the Eu...
- Recolonisation States may be allowed to go bankru...
- Man recognises Britain does not have independent f...
- Why denigrate 'Interests'? Now that the midterm e...
- Cunning Charlie Maybe its what they call a meme, ...
- Saved by the Tories First the Countryside March a...
- Bush saves the Left A nice little piece from Chro...
- Adair Devil Slugger O'Toole has an interesting se...
- La La Land How Iraq might defeat the mighty U.S.A...
- Learn to love the bomb Boris Johnson waxes scepti...
- Odd According to the Torygraph the Iraq dossier h...
- The War Party and Peace Moves A website formed by...
- State of Play An interesting page on the Guardian...
- Africa again Britain sends troops to the Ivory Co...
- The Economy, Stupid Alan Bock asks Will War Wreck...
- Benefit of War Remember those worried about Sadda...
- The Dossier So they've let us see the dossier on ...
- Irrelevant Duncan Smith An article of mine has ap...
- Who you calling Hitler? Jim Henley makes a damn g...
- Iraq ain't fighting fair Jaundiced is one of my h...
- It didn't happen last time One of the unspoken as...
- A Political Party that actively supports the natio...
- Our European Partners Pro-Europeans are typically...
- Over the Pond "In the National Interest" has an i...
- Revenge of the Doves Charles Kennedy sees an adva...
- From the Front1 Conservative anti-interventionist...
- Europe Duffs up Britain Ambrose Evans-Pritchard h...
- I know that demos with CND types and Trots can be ...
- Who's the sick man of Europe now? More on the Ger...
- Taking a constitutional A disturbing letter to th...
- Will Ireland say NO again? I personally think tha...
- Global Police? Statewatchpoints to secret agreem...
- And they want to look after our money More on EU ...
- Woof Woof Iain Murray prompts me to read "An ally...
- The Anglosphere in a nutshell Forget the Anglosph...
- It's not just China German government pressures I...
- Never Knew That France frees Nazi collaborator, a...
- Problems in paradise This one slipped under my ra...
- The mainstream anti-war coalition may be full of d...
- The Principled UN in action UN divided over inspe...
- Why the U.N.? – 17Sep02. If I were an American ha...
- Imperium Whoever wrote this piece for the Scotsma...
- Belly of the Beast There's a Private Eye style ve...
- They've let them in ... but don't expect the Iraq...
- Another Offshore Island A writer from a small ser...
- UNdone The left wing peaceniks look like they've ...
- Oil No doubt there will be many, influenced by th...
- That Speech Justin Raimondo is jaundiced as ever ...
- Get the votes in The Economist sees a shift in Ge...
- Meeting There may be an interesting meeting tonig...
- A Tory MP thinks, shock Peter Ainsworth dares to ...
- As if the national interest mattered Iain Murray ...
- Geopolitics anyone? A new "European Geopolitical ...
- Gabb Again Another mention of Sean Gabb, this tim...
- Update on the European Convention Whereas everybo...
- Gerry goes East Electric Review is getting better...
- Forgetting our history Pat Buchanan has a great p...
- Europe's Coming Round to War It was only a couple...
- Devil or deep blue sea? David Carr over at Samizd...
- Death of an Empire Sean Gabb thinks that the Amer...
- Tory Splits. None Dead Maybe its a sign of irrel...
- The Blairites are coming out Another Blairite com...
- Competing Treacheries So the Tories have this mag...
- Scarier than Hitler, blah, blah, blah An interest...
- 0.00087% That great Kosovo triumph: Attacks on l...
- Beware False Friends. There are many reasons for ...
- Words of War I was going to sneer at Iain Duncan ...
- The Meaning of Patriotism Patriotism is love for ...
-
▼
September
(69)
0 comments:
Post a Comment